← Back to Spindrift Newsletters
Diane Daruty, Editor
Date: September 10, 2026
Exchange – The Exchange Club of Newport Harbor, CA
Ph: 949-322-7949
Vol. 76   No. 10

MEETING President Leo Fracalosy opened. Marianne Amerine read a prayer authored by Leo. Leo led the Pledge.

PROGRAM Diane Daruty introduced Walter Stahr, candidate for Newport City Council. Walter’s parents, who were active in the Girl Scouts, Pacific Symphony, South Coast Repertory, and Newport’s Central Library, were 2016’s Newport Beach Citizens of the Year. Continuing in their tradition, Walter serves on the Boards of the Pacific Symphony and Newport’s Library Foundation. He received an undergraduate degree in political science from Stanford, a juris doctorate from Harvard, and a master’s in public policy from Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government. He practiced law more than two decades with an international law firm and later for the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission and for Fidelity Investments in Asia. In his second career, Walter has authored biographies of American leaders including William H. Seward and Edwin Stanton, influential members of President Lincoln’s cabinet, Salmon P. Chase, Treasury Secretary under Lincoln, John Jay, a Founding Father, and most recently, William Howard Taft, President and Supreme Court Chief Justice. Walter appeared to discuss his candidacy and his book on Taft.

If elected to City Council, Walter seeks to prevent construction of a new police department at the park adjacent to Newport’s Civic Center. He believes that many Newport citizens strongly oppose this because they want to save the park and to prevent a jail located so close to Civic Center. Nevertheless, in his view, the current Council is proceeding full speed ahead with the project, even approving a public relations campaign supporting it.

Walter is committed to being a Council Member who listens to residents and explains the reasoning behind his votes. He expressed disappointment with Erik Weigand, the Council Member who Walter is running to replace, claiming Erik does not listen to citizens. Walter criticized Erik for allegedly telling citizens at a Council meeting that they were wasting Council’s time, he was tired of the same people complaining, and he wanted to hear from others in the community.

Walter also disparaged Erik for being one of four council members who, without explanation, voted to delay a citizen vote on three ballot measures until 2028.

Walter addressed the problems that occurred on July 4th at Newport Peninsula. Although the police made 400 arrests, he questioned the outcome of most of them. He suspects that the vast majority were for minor offenses and that 50 or less resulted in criminal charges. He is also concerned with those who acted criminally but who were not arrested. If elected, he would propose an independent consultant analyze what the police knew about what was brewing in social media that day, what they did about it, and whether their actions adequately addressed the situation. Walter acknowledged that this 4th of July was particularly difficult for law enforcement as it was on a Saturday, making for a long weekend and more persons traveling to Newport to celebrate. Walter discussed his recent book about William Howard Taft that is currently available on Amazon. It will be available in book stores on November 10th and he will give a presentation that day about it at Witte Hall.

Leo & Walter
Leo & Walter

Most know Taft as President. But before his presidency, he was a prosecutor and state and federal court judge; afterwards, a Supreme Court Chief Justice. Taft’s judicial experience equipped him as President to approach issues analytically and to consider all sides. He sought to avoid war and to honor the Constitution. He worked closely with Congress and was willing to work with Republicans and Democrats. Taft was an advocate of the predecessor of NAFTA and almost succeeded until Canada rejected it.

Spindrift September 10, 2026 photo

Walter counts Taft as one of history’s top four Supreme Court Chief Justices. He considers Taft’s leadership in giving the Court control over its calendar as his most significant contribution. When Taft joined the Supreme Court, it was hearing all appeals, with an average of two to three years to resolve each one. The Court was buried in many small and not very meaningful cases, for example those that only made their way to it because the plaintiffs and defendants resided in different states. Taft recognized the significance of the Court’s role and that it was vital that it focus on cases where the outcomes would establish meaningful precedents. Working with the Justice Department and drawing upon on his relationships in Congress, he was pivotal in the passage of the Judges’ Bill of 1925. This bill gave the Supreme Court discretionary control over its caseload by largely eliminating mandatory appeals.

As Chief Justice, Taft essentially selected new justices. This was useful in gaining support for a dedicated home for the Court. When Taft first arrived, the justices had very little office space and most of them worked at home. This was not only inconvenient, but it also prevented the justices from conferring on cases. Once Taft gained a majority of justices in favor of a new building, the land was obtained and the building design confirmed. Although he did not live to see the completed structure, a model of it was displayed next to his casket at his funeral.

Perhaps a less significant but interesting fact was Taft’s stature. By the end of his presidency, he weighed 350 pounds making him the largest president in history. To his credit, working with his doctor to improve his nutrition and add exercise, between the end of his presidency and his death, he lost 100 pounds.

Walter drew the winning raffle ticket. Lisa Jelke and Dave Schapiro each won $25.


The Exchange Club of Newport Harbor
Upcoming Events

DATESPEAKER/SUBJECT
Sept 10Judge Terri Flynn-Peister, Insight into the OC Court system
Sept 17CA Assemblymember Diane Dixon

Lunch will be served at next Thursday’s meeting at 12:20 p.m. You will be emailed an invitation before the meeting. Please notify Leo Fracalosy by Sunday evening if you are planning on attending.

Please visit our website:
www.exchangeclubofnewportharbor.org

Spindrift
EXCHANGE CLUB OF NEWPORT HARBOR
Box 1022, Newport Beach, CA 92659-0022
Newport’s First Service Club, 1926 * Re–Chartered January 18, 1959
Meets at Bahia Corinthian Yacht Club
1601 Bayside Drive, Corona del Mar
Thursdays | 12 Noon
Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top
Secret Link